Elder Scrolls Skyrim Forum Fan Site

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

  • Welcome to Skyrim Forums! Register now to participate using the 'Sign Up' button on the right. You may now register with your Facebook or Steam account!

Imperials or Stormcloaks, what one?

Except it isn't about finding a random person in the street, you were caught with Stormcloaks, you were mistaken for a Stormcloak which would accuse you of treason and insurrection. Lokir did ask the Stormcloaks to tell the Imperials you aren't with them because the punishment is death, he would of faced a fine or imprisonment for stealing a horse, except he was thought to be a Stormcloak. You have no real way to prove your innocence, you have nothing on you, the law is guilty until proven innocent, there for you are already guilty and can be killed. Adding to it that the Thalmor are behind the trouble in Skyrim, if I was in charge I would execute them all also, you don't play what if when it comes to things the Thalmor are behind, you end it and you end it quickly.
I much prefer innocent until proven guilty. I could claim someone murdered my girlfriend, and when they don't find evidence to say the man I claimed murdered him is innocent, he is killed no matter what. Your name isn't on the list that proves you are innocence.

Forget the list. Is just like saying oh we don't have any evidence that you have done a crime or helped the stormcloaks, but who cares we like to kill innocent people. Am I correct in assuming so?
 
I much prefer innocent until proven guilty. I could claim someone murdered my girlfriend, and when they don't find evidence to say the man I claimed murdered him is innocent, he is killed no matter what. Your name isn't on the list that proves you are innocence.

Forget the list. Is just like saying oh we don't have any evidence that you have done a crime or helped the stormcloaks, but who cares we like to kill innocent people. Am I correct in assuming so?

Not being on the list doesn't make you innocent, for what they know there could be many reasons, a mistake on behalf of a subordinate etc. Innocent until proven guilty is great but it isn't how things are done in TES. Forget the list is saying, you've been caught with the Stormcloaks, not just any Stormcloaks but Ulfric and his bodyguards.
 
Anyone notice that only Rikki is the only nord that supports the Empire that is seen in Sovngarde ? I have seen a lot of stormcloaks, but no regular Legionnaires. Maybe Shor isn't too happy at the Nords turning their back on Talos lol.
 
Anyone notice that only Rikki is the only nord that supports the Empire that is seen in Sovngarde ? I have seen a lot of stormcloaks, but no regular Legionnaires. Maybe Shor isn't too happy at the Nords turning their back on Talos lol.

I don't see how Shor would care all that much, Talos isn't even in the Nordic plane of Aetherius. King Torygg is in Sovngarde.
 
I don't see how Shor would care all that much, Talos isn't even in the Nordic plane of Aetherius. King Torygg is in Sovngarde.
I know Toryogg is in Sovngarde, but I have never seen him. Dies he appear if you help the empire? I've seen Ulfric, but never him.
 
You have to also factor in that the Imperials know the Thalmor are behind what is happening in Skyrim, the General knows, officers know. Your word doesn't mean that much when it comes to the larger picture. The head of the Thalmor in Skyrim showed up at Helgan. When they're snooping, you must be certain you end their plans.


This is one of the issues for Stormcloak supporters, small minded not looking the the larger picture, the Thalmor are behind the Civil war in Skyrim, they started stirring up trouble, they're aiding the Stormcloaks. Put yourself in the Legion's shoes, you have a bunch of prisoners that the Thalmor suddenly take a deep interest in, you know the Thalmor are behind the rebellion, you know the goal of the Thalmor is to destroy the Empire, now they're very interested in your prisoners, they don't want there to be an execution because it would harm their plans. The prisoners were originally being taken to Cyrodiil for trial but a slow moving prison transport several weeks from Cyrodiil? You really believe the Thalmor would simply let their plans come to an end because a very slow moving transport is very slowly getting away. Tullius is no fool, it is very clear the Thalmor were keeping a close eye on the transport because they made it to Helgan very quickly when the Legion suddenly diverted, they were waiting for Tullius, they exchanged some words though we couldn't hear them, no doubt it would of been about stopping the execution because they need Ulfric alive and distracting the Empire, making sure the Empire wastes resources and weakens their army on the Aldmeri Dominion border by sending in Legionnaires who are stationed on the border. The Legion in Skyrim has had to recruit locally because the Empire can't weaken their defenses too much.

If what you're saying is true... that the Imperials knows that the Thalmor are behind what is happening in Skyrim, which includes the General... Why they're continuing to feed the Thalmor what they truly desires? To have men fighting against each other so that when the Great War resumes that man would be easily defeated due to lack of resources. Don't you think that the Imperials should act professional, and reason with the Stormcloaks instead of fighting with them? Instead of doing what the Thalmor desires... Tullius should have Legate Rikke go to Windhelm to try to reason with Ulfric, to negotiate with him so that both sides can be satisfied. Perhaps the Empire should surrender Skyrim over to Ulfric in return long life relationship between two countries. That is what I would try to do if I was in the legion shoes. The Thalmor would NEVER dream of the Empire building up an alliance with the Stormcloaks. This would be a HUGE backfire, and besides after the Empire hands over Skyrim to Ulfric the WGC would be invalid thus Ulfrics soldiers would then drive the Thalmor that's already in Skyrim out of the country, and the country can soon rebuild. The Blades would have a safe haven to rebuild, and would be a great asset if persuaded to join in the resumed war against the Aldmeri Dominion... I don't think they would say no, since their already at war with them already.


"Most of the Legion is tied down on the border with the Aldmeri Dominion. The Emperor can't afford to risk weakening Cyrodiil's defenses. From the Imperial City, our war here is just a sideshow. An interlude before the main event against the Thalmor resumes." - Tullius


Like I said Tullius needs to stop feeding the elves because that's exactly what they want, and so far their getting it.

Ulfric: "Stop what? Taking Skyrim back from those who'd leave her to rot?"
Rikke: "You're wrong. Ulfric. We need the Empire. Without it Skyrim will assuredly fall to the Dominion."


Is the other way around :) The Empire needs Skyrim more than Skyrim needs the Empire.

Tullius: "You realize this is exactly what they wanted."
Galmar: "What who wanted?"
Tullius: "The Thalmor. They stirred up trouble here. Forced us to divert needed resources and throw away good soldiers quelling this rebellion."


Oh Tullius I'm appalled in your leadership. This whole entire time you knew that this is what the Thalmor had wanted and YOU deliberately giving in to what they wanted this entire time?!??! You just now say this just when you're about to die? Shame on you. Go meet your new masters in Oblivion :)

The Aldmeri Dominion is something that Skyrim cannot beat alone, they can't even face all out war with the Empire, yet they plan to attack the Aldmeri Dominion?

"We're ready to march on Solitude, but the Emperor's cousin is getting married! If royal blood was spilt, all of Cyrodiil would be up in arms. We can't afford an all out war with the Empire. So we'll bide our time for now." - Ulfric Stormcloak


Ulfric doesn't want an all out war against the Empire because their not the true target. Why should he go after the Empire when his primary objective is to go after the elves? Ulfric knows his limits. Hes no fool. If he does kill the Emperor all of his planning to go after the elves will go to wastes because he would be dealing with the Empire instead.

"First we'll kick the Thalmor and their bloody Imperial puppets out of the country. Then we'll rebuild Skyrim into the land she once was. When we are done with that, we will take our army to the Dominion, and show those pointy-eared bastards not every man is fit to be their slave." - Galmar Stone-Fist
"Because getting rid of the Empire was only half the problem. Soon, the elves will again seek to rule the world. We must ready ourselves to fight them. For it will be Skyrim that shall lead Tamriel in those dark days, when the fate of the world is finally determined." - Ulfric Stormcloak

The real threat is the Aldmeri Dominion and the only way to defeat that is if man is united, that will include Hammerfell which hopefully will be able to mend their relations with the Empire once more.

I can agree with this part. Man should unite (even if it's temporary) for this special occasion. The Stormcloaks and the Empire should work together instead of fighting with each other. Hammerfell should also unite, even if it's temp.

In my POV you don't need to be part of the Empire... or even a province of the Empire to fight against the elves. You're fighting to prove your strength and domination. To prove that you're not the beta but an ALPHA. To prove to the elves that you are far more superior than they are. The elves from the Aldmeri Dominion are way past due for an ass kicking by man. I can only hope that Bethesda would create something like this.

There can be no doubt that the current peace cannot last forever. The Thalmor take the long view, as is proved by the sequence of events leading up to the Great War. All those who value freedom over tyranny can only hope that before it is too late, Hammerfell and the Empire will be reconciled and stand united against the Thalmor threat. Otherwise, any hope to stem the tide of Thalmor rule over all of Tamriel is dimmed. - The Great War
You claim you like Tiber Septim, yet Stormcloaks are destroying his Empire, disbanding the Third Empire and thus ending the great Empire of Tiber Septim. Skyrim is not only strategically important to the Empire currently, it is also symbolic, Skyrim and Cyrodiil conquered Tamriel together, the removing of Skyrim is the real end of Tiber Septim's Empire.

Ulfric isn't destroying Talos Empire because Mede already did by banning the worship of Talos. It was a big thing back in Oblivion years... I can only imagine how depressing the Imperial city looks now. Those beautiful statues of Talos gone because of Mede II.


Jora:"You know about Talos? He founded the Empire!"
Jora:"We're the only Temple in Skyrim that can openly worship Talos."
Jora: "Those awful Thalmor can't touch us, thanks to Ulfric."
Jora: "I can't believe the Empire would turn its back on Talos."

Jora gives you some background about Talos: "Talos, who in life was known as Tiber Septim, united Tamriel and founded the Empire. He was rewarded for his deeds by being joined with the Divines in eternal glory. The only mortal to do so. We worship him that we might follow in his path. We can't literally join him in the heavens, but we may do our best to know them here on Nirn."

Jora: "The Empire's elven puppetmasters never cared much for the idea of a human becoming a divine. So the worship of Talos is outlawed. Skyrim doesn't take kindly to being told what to do. And to try and forget Talos, well... they may as well ordered us all to cut off our ears."

If the Imperials win the civil war this is the dialogue that she gives to you.

Jora: "Ulfric Stormcloak was a true hero of Skyrim. He stood up to the Thalmor and refused to turn his back on Talos." and "The Stormcloaks are gone, but Talos will never be forgotten. I don't care what the Thalmor say!"

When asked what she feels about Ulfric’s death, she will angrily say: "I don't care what the Imperials say -- when Ulfric Stormcloak died, one of Skyrim's greatest heroes was lost. Now at last, the Thalmor will get their way. The worship of Talos will finally be stamped out. Or so they think. Those true sons and daughters of Skyrim will never cease to worship mighty Talos. If we cannot do so in our temples, we will do so in our hearts. Oblivion take the Thalmor! I'll never give up Talos, not even if it means my life. Let them come and make me a martyr!"

Jora - pro Stormcloak Talos priestess

Lortheim: "I've spent my life serving Talos. I don't plan to stop now, no matter what the Empire says."
Lortheim: "Talos created the Empire. You'd think they'd show him more respect."

If the Imperials win the war

Lortheim: "With Ulfric dead and the Stormcloaks gone, who will have the courage to champion the cause of Talos?"

If it wasn't for the protection of Ulfric both Lortheim and Jora would've been snatched up by the Thalmor by now, and tossed away in their Thalmor run prison all thanks to the Empire and their damn treaty.
 
If what you're saying is true... that the Imperials knows that the Thalmor are behind what is happening in Skyrim, which includes the General... Why they're continuing to feed the Thalmor what they truly desires? To have men fighting against each other so that when the Great War resumes that man would be easily defeated due to lack of resources. Don't you think that the Imperials should act professional, and reason with the Stormcloaks instead of fighting with them? Instead of doing what the Thalmor desires... Tullius should have Legate Rikke go to Windhelm to try to reason with Ulfric, to negotiate with him so that both sides can be satisfied. Perhaps the Empire should surrender Skyrim over to Ulfric in return long life relationship between two countries. That is what I would try to do if I was in the legion shoes. The Thalmor would NEVER dream of the Empire building up an alliance with the Stormcloaks. This would be a HUGE backfire, and besides after the Empire hands over Skyrim to Ulfric the WGC would be invalid thus Ulfrics soldiers would then drive the Thalmor that's already in Skyrim out of the country, and the country can soon rebuild. The Blades would have a safe haven to rebuild, and would be a great asset if persuaded to join in the resumed war against the Aldmeri Dominion... I don't think they would say no, since their already at war with them already.




Like I said Tullius needs to stop feeding the elves because that's exactly what they want, and so far their getting it.



Is the other way around :) The Empire needs Skyrim more than Skyrim needs the Empire.



Oh Tullius I'm appalled in your leadership. This whole entire time you knew that this is what the Thalmor had wanted and YOU deliberately giving in to what they wanted this entire time?!??! You just now say this just when you're about to die? Shame on you. Go meet your new masters in Oblivion :)



Ulfric doesn't want an all out war against the Empire because their not the true target. Why should he go after the Empire when his primary objective is to go after the elves? Ulfric knows his limits. Hes no fool. If he does kill the Emperor all of his planning to go after the elves will go to wastes because he would be dealing with the Empire instead.



I can agree with this part. Man should unite (even if it's temporary) for this special occasion. The Stormcloaks and the Empire should work together instead of fighting with each other. Hammerfell should also unite, even if it's temp.

In my POV you don't need to be part of the Empire... or even a province of the Empire to fight against the elves. You're fighting to prove your strength and domination. To prove that you're not the beta but an ALPHA. To prove to the elves that you are far more superior than they are. The elves from the Aldmeri Dominion are way past due for an ass kicking by man. I can only hope that Bethesda would create something like this.



Ulfric isn't destroying Talos Empire because Mede already did by banning the worship of Talos. It was a big thing back in Oblivion years... I can only imagine how depressing the Imperial city looks now. Those beautiful statues of Talos gone because of Mede II.


Jora:"You know about Talos? He founded the Empire!"
Jora:"We're the only Temple in Skyrim that can openly worship Talos."
Jora: "Those awful Thalmor can't touch us, thanks to Ulfric."
Jora: "I can't believe the Empire would turn its back on Talos."

Jora gives you some background about Talos: "Talos, who in life was known as Tiber Septim, united Tamriel and founded the Empire. He was rewarded for his deeds by being joined with the Divines in eternal glory. The only mortal to do so. We worship him that we might follow in his path. We can't literally join him in the heavens, but we may do our best to know them here on Nirn."

Jora: "The Empire's elven puppetmasters never cared much for the idea of a human becoming a divine. So the worship of Talos is outlawed. Skyrim doesn't take kindly to being told what to do. And to try and forget Talos, well... they may as well ordered us all to cut off our ears."

If the Imperials win the civil war this is the dialogue that she gives to you.

Jora: "Ulfric Stormcloak was a true hero of Skyrim. He stood up to the Thalmor and refused to turn his back on Talos." and "The Stormcloaks are gone, but Talos will never be forgotten. I don't care what the Thalmor say!"

When asked what she feels about Ulfric’s death, she will angrily say: "I don't care what the Imperials say -- when Ulfric Stormcloak died, one of Skyrim's greatest heroes was lost. Now at last, the Thalmor will get their way. The worship of Talos will finally be stamped out. Or so they think. Those true sons and daughters of Skyrim will never cease to worship mighty Talos. If we cannot do so in our temples, we will do so in our hearts. Oblivion take the Thalmor! I'll never give up Talos, not even if it means my life. Let them come and make me a martyr!"

Jora - pro Stormcloak Talos priestess

Lortheim: "I've spent my life serving Talos. I don't plan to stop now, no matter what the Empire says."
Lortheim: "Talos created the Empire. You'd think they'd show him more respect."

If the Imperials win the war

Lortheim: "With Ulfric dead and the Stormcloaks gone, who will have the courage to champion the cause of Talos?"

If it wasn't for the protection of Ulfric both Lortheim and Jora would've been snatched up by the Thalmor by now, and tossed away in their Thalmor run prison all thanks to the Empire and their damn treaty.


There is no reasoning with Ulfric, the Empire should not just simply hand over Skyrim to him because he has a little pout. He killed the High King and is guilty of High Treason. Simply handing him Skyrim would breach the WGC and end the treaty, the Empire is not ready to end the Treaty, the armies are not ready, you think the Thalmor would sit around while we wait for Skyrim to prepare itself. Everything you believe about Ulfric goes against his character, goes against everything shown. Ulfric would not ally himself with the Empire, he would not simply turn over to reason, it would not make a good song if he were to simply make deals with the Empire. You blame Tullius for upholding the law? Defending those in Skyrim who don't want Ulfric's rule. Not just Imperials, not just Dunmer but Nords as well. If you stop putting light on Ulfric like he is the second coming of Talos for ten seconds, you would see more logic. You're either with Ulfric or you're against him, no one in their right mind hands over the entire province to him because he is angry, he is driven by hatred and is unfit to rule. How can the man run Skyrim is he can hardly run his own city.

The Stormcloaks and Empire would never work together, so get that idea far out of your head. Ulfric forced the Empire's hand when he assassinated King Torygg. You are showing your Stormcloak side once more, you know the Thalmor and you are very alike. "Show them who is superior" "Proving strength and domination" Not every Elf likes the Thalmor. Perhaps you should join their ranks.

It isn't called the Talos Empire, it is called the Third Empire, Tiber Septim's Empire. He is destroying it, because it wouldn't be an Empire if it is just Cyrodiil. Empire, Noun; An extensive group of states or countries under a single supreme authority, formerly esp. an emperor or empress. The statue would remain, it is a statue of Tiber Septim, although some things may of been damaged when the Dominion took the Imperial City.

Many in the Empire still worship Talos... Every Talos worshiper death by the Thalmor is on Ufric's head because he wanted to be High King and shout about Talos. No one paid attention to the treaty until Ulfric started screaming about Talos and how the Empire has banned it, the ban was never enforced, but the Thalmor started putting pressure on the Empire because of Ulfric.

"We didn't pay much attention to it when I was a boy - everyone still had their little shrine to Talos. But then Ulfric and his "Sons of Skyrim" started agitating about it, and sure enough the Emperor had to crack down." - Alvor
 
There is no reasoning with Ulfric, the Empire should not just simply hand over Skyrim to him because he has a little pout. He killed the High King and is guilty of High Treason. Simply handing him Skyrim would breach the WGC and end the treaty, the Empire is not ready to end the Treaty, the armies are not ready, you think the Thalmor would sit around while we wait for Skyrim to prepare itself. Everything you believe about Ulfric goes against his character, goes against everything shown. Ulfric would not ally himself with the Empire, he would not simply turn over to reason, it would not make a good song if he were to simply make deals with the Empire. You blame Tullius for upholding the law? Defending those in Skyrim who don't want Ulfric's rule. Not just Imperials, not just Dunmer but Nords as well. If you stop putting light on Ulfric like he is the second coming of Talos for ten seconds, you would see more logic. You're either with Ulfric or you're against him, no one in their right mind hands over the entire province to him because he is angry, he is driven by hatred and is unfit to rule. How can the man run Skyrim is he can hardly run his own city.

Ulfric killed the High King in fair battle, how is that High treason when the King himself accepted the duel? Perhaps the Empire should decapitate the deceased Kings head for committing high treason too. It only seems fair. Why shouldn't the Empire hand over Skyrim to Ulfric when they can't even defend their own country against the elves? With the Legion in Skyrim gone, and return to Cyrodiil their defenses would be stronger. Not ready you say? When will they be ready? By the end of time? The more time they wait the stronger the Aldmeri Dominion gets, don't forget that either. Skyrim doesn't need a weak Empire to rule her.

The Stormcloaks and Empire would never work together, so get that idea far out of your head. Ulfric forced the Empire's hand when he assassinated King Torygg. You are showing your Stormcloak side once more, you know the Thalmor and you are very alike. "Show them who is superior" "Proving strength and domination" Not every Elf likes the Thalmor. Perhaps you should join their ranks.

An enemy of my enemy is my friend :)

Many in the Empire still worship Talos... Every Talos worshiper death by the Thalmor is on Ufric's head because he wanted to be High King and shout about Talos. No one paid attention to the treaty until Ulfric started screaming about Talos and how the Empire has banned it, the ban was never enforced, but the Thalmor started putting pressure on the Empire because of Ulfric.

Oh will you stop blaming Ulfric on the Empires problems? Ulfric did not invited the Thalmor to come down to Skyrim, and hunt down Talos worshipers. Mede II did by signing the treaty to ban the worship of Talos.

"We didn't pay much attention to it when I was a boy - everyone still had their little shrine to Talos. But then Ulfric and his "Sons of Skyrim" started agitating about it, and sure enough the Emperor had to crack down." - Alvor

Gerdur: The Empire may have been good for Skyrim once upon a time, but those days are long past. Banning the worship of Talos was the last straw. Thalmor everywhere, dragging people off for honoring our own gods!
 
Ulfric killed the High King in fair battle, how is that High treason when the King himself accepted the duel? Perhaps the Empire should decapitate the deceased Kings head for committing high treason too. It only seems fair. Why shouldn't the Empire hand over Skyrim to Ulfric when they can't even defend their own country against the elves? With the Legion in Skyrim gone, and return to Cyrodiil their defenses would be stronger. Not ready you say? When will they be ready? By the end of time? The more time they wait the stronger the Aldmeri Dominion gets, don't forget that either. Skyrim doesn't need a weak Empire to rule her.



An enemy of my enemy is my friend :)



Oh will you stop blaming Ulfric on the Empires problems? Ulfric did not invited the Thalmor to come down to Skyrim, and hunt down Talos worshipers. Mede II did by signing the treaty to ban the worship of Talos. .



Gerdur: The Empire may have been good for Skyrim once upon a time, but those days are long past. Banning the worship of Talos was the last straw. Thalmor everywhere, dragging people off for honoring our own gods!

Fair battle? Is using ancient magic and slaughtering a man while he's on the ground fair and honorable? I've come across Bandits with more honor. It's High Treason because he killed the High King, it's High Treason to many Nords because he broke the agreement of the duel, hence why half of Skyrim is up in arms against him.
The Empire's own 'country' is many Provinces, Cyrodiil is a part of the Empire same as Skyrim. They did defend Cyrodiil, they defeated the main Aldmeri Dominion army in Cyrodiil... if that's not defending I don't know what is? Because Ulfric is driven by hatred, he would never ally himself with the Empire, before he even killed the High King. He would rather see Skyrim burn, their people slaughtered before he would ever ally himself with the Empire. His hatred for them is personal because of the death of his father when he was in Imperial prison, he couldn't be there with his father. He hates them all and would not be a good leader because he can't get over his anger. The more they wait the Empire gets stronger also, you should remember that as well.

Only seems fair, you blame Mede because he didn't agree to the Terms of the Thalmor to begin with, you blame Mede for fighting against the Aldmeri Dominion, you also blame Mede because the Thalmor killed all the Blades agents in Valenwood and Summerset Isles before they even met with Mede to deliver terms. So perhaps you should stop blaming Titus Mede II for every little thing you can come up with to back a weak standing argument.

Who brought the Thalmor everywhere? Ulfric Stormcloak, his actions caused the Thalmor to put pressure on the Empire. No one was getting dragged off in the night for secret worship until Ulfric and the True Sons of Skyrim started. Before Ulfric stirring up things it took the Thalmor an entire week to arrest a man who was singing songs about Talos, everyday for an entire week
 
Fair battle? Is using ancient magic and slaughtering a man while he's on the ground fair and honorable? I've come across Bandits with more honor. It's High Treason because he killed the High King, it's High Treason to many Nords because he broke the agreement of the duel, hence why half of Skyrim is up in arms against him.
The Empire's own 'country' is many Provinces, Cyrodiil is a part of the Empire same as Skyrim. They did defend Cyrodiil, they defeated the main Aldmeri Dominion army in Cyrodiil... if that's not defending I don't know what is? Because Ulfric is driven by hatred, he would never ally himself with the Empire, before he even killed the High King. He would rather see Skyrim burn, their people slaughtered before he would ever ally himself with the Empire. His hatred for them is personal because of the death of his father when he was in Imperial prison, he couldn't be there with his father. He hates them all and would not be a good leader because he can't get over his anger. The more they wait the Empire gets stronger also, you should remember that as well.

Only seems fair, you blame Mede because he didn't agree to the Terms of the Thalmor to begin with, you blame Mede for fighting against the Aldmeri Dominion, you also blame Mede because the Thalmor killed all the Blades agents in Valenwood and Summerset Isles before they even met with Mede to deliver terms. So perhaps you should stop blaming Titus Mede II for every little thing you can come up with to back a weak standing argument.

Who brought the Thalmor everywhere? Ulfric Stormcloak, his actions caused the Thalmor to put pressure on the Empire. No one was getting dragged off in the night for secret worship until Ulfric and the True Sons of Skyrim started. Before Ulfric stirring up things it took the Thalmor an entire week to arrest a man who was singing songs about Talos, everyday for an entire week
I hate when people say Ulfric cheated.
First, where was it in the ANCIENT NORDIC duel rule book do they say you can't use the ANCIENT NORDIC art of the thu'um?

Second, is it dishonorable when the dragonborn uses a shout in combat and hitting a opponent on the ground?

Going back to the the duel disagreement, two dragons using the thu'um is like a debate match they say. I believe the ancient Nords who did the duels uses shouts a ton. You see the old Nords in Sovngrade they seem to use shouts a lot. To argue that Ulfric can't use the thu'um for one of its main uses(combat) is foolish. Ancient Nords probably used shouts for duels is very likely. What I'm trying to stress is Thu'um is a weapon Ulfric can use, and the Thu'um was a very common thing back in the 1 era in Skyrim. Don't accept the Ancient Nordic duel if you can handle the Thu'um.
 
I hate when people say Ulfric cheated.
First, where was it in the ANCIENT NORDIC duel rule book do they say you can't use the ANCIENT NORDIC art of the thu'um?

Second, is it dishonorable when the dragonborn uses a shout in combat and hitting a opponent on the ground?

Going back to the the duel disagreement, two dragons using the thu'um is like a debate match they say. I believe the ancient Nords who did the duels uses shouts a ton. You see the old Nords in Sovngrade they seem to use shouts a lot. To argue that Ulfric can't use the thu'um for one of its main uses(combat) is foolish. Ancient Nords probably used shouts for duels is very likely. What I'm trying to stress is Thu'um is a weapon Ulfric can use, and the Thu'um was a very common thing back in the 1 era in Skyrim. Don't accept the Ancient Nordic duel if you can handle the Thu'um.

I didn't say he cheated, just many don't consider it fair and honorable. Where does it say you can't use the Thu'um for violence? That would of probably come up around the time when the Way of the Voice began around the beginning of the First Era which would make it very old to be already tradition. The dragonborn is the exception to the rule, the blessing was given directly from Akatosh. The last war leader who used the voice as a weapon his armies were defeated and he came to realize it was punishment from the Gods for his misuse of the voice for his own gain. Thus the way of the voice began as a way of honoring the Gods, Ulfric who studied with the Greybeards would well know the tale of how the way of the voice came to be, that the Dragonborn is the exception. Perhaps that is why he used it in the duel, he didn't need to use it but he wanted the killing of Torygg to be a message. Now which would make a better story? Simply killing the High King or using the voice, the thu'um that Talos himself used. The Nords who are shouting in Sovngarde go back further than the First Era, those three heroes of old are from the time of Dragons when a God took pity and Paarthurnax taught them. It was a Common thing in the First Era for the Way of the Voice. Wasn't until Tiber Septim opened the Imperial College of the Voice in Markarth, did that be more for the art of war, this mind you was during the Late Second Era/ Early Third. However as we can see, that Imperial College no longer stands, so the way of the voice remains.

Take a look at anyone who used the voice for violence, besides those three heroes of old who used the voice in true time of need. They're all dead or injured, Nord armies destroyed when the voice was used for conquest, there was a recorded instance where a young master of the voice used his voice against dragon priest cultist stronghold for the army of the High King I believe, he got an arrow in the throat. Tiber Septim? His throat was slit and he had to lead his armies with a whisper. Ulfric? Well that remains to be decided. We as the Dragonborn? Well who knows what fate has in store for us, except following the current trend I wouldn't be surprised if we're killed or have our throat slit like Tiber. I don't know about you, but to me that says using the voice for violence for personal gain pisses off certain Gods.
 
I hate when people say Ulfric cheated.
First, where was it in the ANCIENT NORDIC duel rule book do they say you can't use the ANCIENT NORDIC art of the thu'um?

Second, is it dishonorable when the dragonborn uses a shout in combat and hitting a opponent on the ground?

Going back to the the duel disagreement, two dragons using the thu'um is like a debate match they say. I believe the ancient Nords who did the duels uses shouts a ton. You see the old Nords in Sovngrade they seem to use shouts a lot. To argue that Ulfric can't use the thu'um for one of its main uses(combat) is foolish. Ancient Nords probably used shouts for duels is very likely. What I'm trying to stress is Thu'um is a weapon Ulfric can use, and the Thu'um was a very common thing back in the 1 era in Skyrim. Don't accept the Ancient Nordic duel if you can handle the Thu'um.

First, duels are illegal in Skyrim, you cannot kill the High King for whatever reason you may be thinking of, to do so is to commit High Treason, a crime which is punished with death by decapitation.

Second, the purpose of the duel is to determine in fair and honorable combat who is the best one to rule Skyrim (a moronic, backwards assumption given how martial prowess has nothing to do with the capacity to rule a nation), to use the Thu'um in such a situation is a violation to the standards by which the duel is done in the first place.

Third, the Dragonborn doesn't duel anyone to honorable and fair challenges everytime he encounters those who seek to harm him/her.

Fourth, Torygg had to accept the challenge, had he refused, Ulfric could've called a new moot, which would've endangered Skyrim's standing with the White-Gold Concordat, that could not happen.

Finally:

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought
The killing of High King Torygg by the hand of Jarl Ulfric Stormcloak was murder.
 
First, duels are illegal in Skyrim, you cannot kill the High King for whatever reason you may be thinking of, to do so is to commit High Treason, a crime which is punished with death by decapitation.

Second, the purpose of the duel is to determine in fair and honorable combat who is the best one to rule Skyrim (a moronic, backwards assumption given how martial prowess has nothing to do with the capacity to rule a nation), to use the Thu'um in such a situation is a violation to the standards by which the duel is done in the first place.

Third, the Dragonborn doesn't duel anyone to honorable and fair challenges everytime he encounters those who seek to harm him/her.

Fourth, Torygg had to accept the challenge, had he refused, Ulfric could've called a new moot, which would've endangered Skyrim's standing with the White-Gold Concordat, that could not happen.

Finally:

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought

Malice Aforethought
The killing of High King Torygg by the hand of Jarl Ulfric Stormcloak was murder.
Now when you brawl against an Orc chieftain would you say it is for honor?( I kinda do, but at the same time it isn't very huge deal it seems to the orcs) is it dishonorable if I use slow time to get in a few extra punches?
 
Now when you brawl against an Orc chieftain would you say it is for honor?( I kinda do, but at the same time it isn't very huge deal it seems to the orcs) is it dishonorable if I use slow time to get in a few extra punches?

Brawl and kill are two different things. Yes that would be dishonorable, Orcs are extremely honorable fighters, having to use magic for an advantage is not honorable in a test of endurance. That is what Nords would call being a milk-drinker.
 
Brawl and kill are two different things. Yes that would be dishonorable, Orcs are extremely honorable fighters, having to use magic for an advantage is not honorable in a test of endurance. That is what Nords would call being a milk-drinker.
Oh I could beat him normally, it just speeds up time XD.
 
Back
Top